Mushy rice is soft, sticky and broken, with grains that have melted into each other instead of standing apart. It is nearly always down to how it was cooked, not the rice itself, and the fixes are simple.
I cook rice two very different ways on this site: a paella that is left alone in a wide pan, and the vegetable pulao that goes with my tandoori chicken. Both are built to stop the rice going mushy, so here is what is going on. Fried rice is the other way round: for my hibachi fried rice the rice is cooked the day before, because cold rice is firmer and the grains stay whole in the pan.
If you cook rice ahead like that, cool it fast. Rice can carry spores that can survive cooking, and if it sits warm they can make toxins that reheating will not remove. Spread it out on a clean tray rather than leaving it in the pan, get it into the fridge within an hour, use it within 24 hours, and reheat it only once, until steaming hot. My guide to cooling rice and other cooked food has the detail.
The short answer
Rice goes mushy when there is too much loose starch and too much liquid. Starch rubbed off the outside of the grains turns the cooking liquid into glue, and grains that are stirred once they have softened break apart. Rinsing, measuring the liquid, leaving it alone and resting it all stop that.
What is going on
A rice grain is mostly starch. As it cooks it soaks up water, swells and softens. There are two kinds of starch in rice. One packs tightly and needs more heat, water and time to soften, the other is looser and softens more easily. Long-grain rice like basmati has more of the tight kind, so it cooks up firm and separate. Short-grain rice has less of it, and sticky rice has almost none, which is why those cook up soft and clingy.
The outside of a dry grain is also dusted with loose starch. In the pot that starch dissolves into the liquid and makes it thick and sticky.
The things that make it mushy
- Stirring once it has softened. Stirring rubs starch off the grains, which is exactly what risotto wants and paella does not. Stirring late in the cooking also breaks the softened grains apart. In my paella, once the prawns go in, the rice is left completely alone.
- Not rinsing. Rinsing the dry rice washes off the loose starch on the outside. I wash the basmati for the pulao until the water runs clearer. One thing to know: a lot of rice grown in the US is enriched with added vitamins, and USA Rice points out that rinsing washes those off, so with American long-grain rice it is a trade-off.
- Too much liquid. Rice can only take up so much water. Give it more and the grains get oversaturated and turn mushy. Vegetables also give up water as they cook, on top of the stock. In my paella the mushrooms and tomatoes add a fair bit, so if they are very juicy I hold back the last 50 to 100 ml of stock and only add it if the pan dries out. Stock can always go in, it cannot come out.
- The wrong rice for the job. Use the rice the recipe was written for. Bomba for paella takes up a lot of liquid without breaking down. Swap in a softer rice and the same amount of liquid will turn it to mush.
How to fix mushy rice
Once rice has gone mushy you cannot turn it back into separate grains, so the real fix is knowing why it happened. Go back through the list above: too much water, stirring once it had softened, no rinse, or the wrong rice for the job. The table below gives the amount of water for each kind of rice, so measure it instead of guessing and it will not happen again.
If the grains are soft but still whole, do not throw it away. Spread it on a tray and chill it, and use it for fried rice. Rice for fried rice should be cold anyway, because chilled rice is firmer and the grains stay whole in the pan, which is why I cook it the day before for my hibachi fried rice. Cool it quickly and use it within 24 hours, as above.
Soaking and resting
Some rice, like basmati and Japanese rice, is soaked for a while before cooking. The grains take up some water first, so they cook faster in the pot. My pulao rice soaks for 30 to 50 minutes.
Resting at the end matters just as much. Cooked rice that sits for a few minutes cools slightly and firms up, so the grains do not break when you scoop them out. My pulao rests covered for 15 minutes off the heat, and the paella rests for 5.
Getting the water right
The best way to stop rice going mushy is to give it the right amount of water in the first place. Each type takes a different amount. These are the stovetop figures from Utah State University Extension, measured by volume: bring the water and rice to the boil, cover, turn the heat down low, and cook for the time given.
| Rice | 1 cup of dry rice weighs | Water | Cooking time |
|---|---|---|---|
| White long grain, including basmati and jasmine | 185 g / 6.5 oz | 1 3/4 cups / 415 ml | 18 to 20 minutes |
| White medium or short grain | 195 to 200 g / 6.9 to 7.1 oz | 1 1/2 cups / 355 ml | 25 to 30 minutes |
| Parboiled | 185 g / 6.5 oz | 2 cups / 475 ml | 25 to 30 minutes |
| Brown long grain | 185 g / 6.5 oz | 2 1/4 cups / 530 ml | 40 to 45 minutes |
| Brown basmati or brown jasmine | 185 g / 6.5 oz | 2 cups / 475 ml | 40 to 45 minutes |
| Brown medium grain | 190 g / 6.7 oz | 2 cups / 475 ml | 30 to 35 minutes |
| Brown short grain | not listed | 2 cups / 475 ml | 40 minutes |
| Black rice | not listed | 1 3/4 to 2 cups / 415 to 475 ml | 30 to 45 minutes |
| Red rice | not listed | 2 to 3 cups / 475 to 710 ml | 20 to 45 minutes |
Jasmine is a long grain but cooks softer and stickier than basmati, so do not expect separate grains from it. The weights are for one US cup of raw rice, from the USDA food tables, and a US cup of water is about 237 ml. If you weigh your rice instead of using a cup, the amount of water stays the same for that weight. Use the same cup for the rice and the water, check the rice at the end of the time, and give it a few more minutes if it needs it. Then leave it covered for 5 to 10 minutes before serving. If your packet gives its own figures, follow those.
Rice cooked in a dish with other ingredients is different, because they add liquid of their own. My paella is 600 ml of stock to 250 g of bomba, and the pulao is 550 ml of stock to 300 g of soaked basmati. Follow the recipe for those rather than the table.
You might also like:
