Why Does My Cheesecake Crack or Sink?

Share this recipe

A cheesecake that cracks across the top has not gone wrong in the way most people think. It tastes exactly the same. But it is annoying, and it is nearly always the same cause: air and heat doing something to the filling that you did not ask for.

I bake a Polish cheesecake, sernik, with a kilo of curd cheese, and it does not crack. That is not luck. Every step of the method is there to stop one particular thing from happening, and once you know what it is, the rules are easy to remember.

The short answer

A cheesecake cracks because the filling rises while it bakes and then falls as it cools, and the top does not come back down evenly. Anything that makes it rise more makes it crack more: beating in air, a hot oven, baking it too long, and cooling it too fast.

What is going on in the oven

A cheesecake is an egg custard with a lot of cheese in it. The eggs are what set it. While it bakes, every air bubble you beat in and the steam from the water in the cheese expands and pushes the filling up. For a sponge or a soufflé that is the point. For a cheesecake it is the opposite of what you want, because the whole idea is a dense, creamy slice.

Then it comes out and cools, and that air and steam shrinks back. The filling drops, and a surface that has set pulls in unevenly. That is a crack, or a sunken middle, or both. The slower the cooling happens, the more gently the surface is pulled in, which is why almost every fix is about being gentle and slow.

Why did my cheesecake sink in the middle?

A sunken middle is the same problem as a crack, just showing up in a different way. The filling rose in the oven and fell as it cooled. If the edge has set firmly and the middle has not, the middle drops further and you get a dip instead of a crack, or a dip with a crack round it.

So the causes are the same four: too much air beaten in, an oven that is too hot, baking it too long, and cooling it too fast. A cheesecake that puffs up high in the oven, especially one with whipped egg whites folded in, will always come down again.

Check the middle before it comes out. It should have a slight wobble, like a set jelly, not a ripple like a liquid. If it still ripples, give it another ten minutes at the low temperature. If it has already sunk, fill the dip with fruit or whipped cream and serve it like that. It tastes the same.

How to prevent cheesecake from cracking: the four things that stop it

  • Beat it slowly, and only until it is even. Vigorous or long beating puts in more air bubbles, and each one fills with steam in the oven. I mix on a spoon or a hand mixer on its lowest speed, and the eggs go in one at a time, only until each one disappears.
  • Bake it low and slow. A hot oven drives the steam out fast and unevenly. Mine goes 20 minutes at 190°C, then 30 minutes at 150°C, then 30 minutes at 120°C.
  • Do not overbake it. Past the point where it has set, the filling dries out and shrinks as it loses moisture. A cheesecake should still have a slight wobble in the middle when it comes out, and it carries on setting as it cools.
  • Cool it gradually. Mine stays in the oven with the door shut for ten minutes, then I open the door a little at a time over the next ten to fifteen minutes before it comes out. Taking it straight from a hot oven into a cool kitchen is the quickest way to a crack.

Why I do not whip the egg whites

Plenty of sernik recipes have you whip the whites and fold them in. It gives a beautiful rise in the oven, and then it sinks the moment it cools, often cracking on the way down. That is the air doing exactly what I have described above. My recipe uses whole eggs beaten gently into the cheese, and the butter goes in melted and cooled instead of creamed, for the same reason. I get a dense, creamy crumb that holds its shape and does not sink.

Do you need a water bath?

Not for mine. Some people stand the tin in a bath of hot water to give a gentler, steamier bake. If you want a little of that without the faff, a small ovenproof dish of just boiled water on a lower shelf of the oven does the job, and the tin does not need to sit in it. The slow temperature step down does most of the same work.

Does the cheese or the starch matter?

Both do a little. A lot of cheesecake recipes add a spoonful of flour or cornflour to help the filling hold together and to take up any water the fresh cheese lets go of. Mine has 40 g of potato starch for a kilo of cheese. And full fat twaróg matters: a low fat cheese gives a drier cake that is quicker to overbake. If you want to go all the way, you can make your own twaróg.

If it has already cracked

It will still taste right. Dust the top with icing sugar, or pour over a little chocolate ganache, which is what I would do, and nobody will know. Then make a note to leave the oven door alone next time and give it the slow cool.

The same rules for other baked cheesecakes

Nothing here is specific to Polish cheesecake. My Biscoff cheesecake is baked, and it follows the same logic: a gentle whisk, a low oven at 150°C, and a wobble left in the middle when it comes out.

You might also like:

Enjoyed it? Share it

Made it? Tell me how it went

Tell me what you changed and how it turned out, or ask a question about the recipe. No email needed.

Please read the Comment Policy before you comment. Comments are for adults and are moderated.