My pan seared scallops are cooked in butter only. They go in until nicely brown, then I flip them, add garlic and baste them with the butter, and finish the pan with white wine, lemon and parsley. About six minutes in the pan.
The two things that make the difference are good scallops and drying them well. Below I explain how I pick them, fresh or frozen, and how many to buy for a starter or a main.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Pin itPan Seared Scallops in Garlic Butter
Scallops need very little: a hot pan, butter and a few minutes. The crust comes from leaving them alone on the first side. The garlic, wine, lemon and parsley all go in at the end, so nothing burns and the butter becomes the sauce.
What Scallops Are
A scallop is a shellfish, and the part we eat is the big round muscle it uses to swim. Scallops move by clapping their shells together, which is why that muscle is tender and sweet, while mussels and clams are chewy.
Next to it sits a small, tougher muscle that held the shell shut. That is the side muscle you pull off before cooking. Large sea scallops come from deep, cold water; small bay scallops are gathered closer to the shore. In the US you usually get only the white muscle, while in Europe they often come with the orange roe still on.
How to Buy Good Scallops
Here is what I look for, fresh or frozen.
- Fresh is best. Buy them from a fishmonger or a fish counter you trust, and cook them the same day or the next.
- Look at the colour. Untreated scallops are a slightly dull off white, often with a pink or orange tint. Very bright, glossy white scallops sitting in a milky liquid have usually been soaked.
- Smell them. They should smell clean, like the sea. A strong fishy smell means they are past their best.
- Ask for dry scallops. Soaked scallops are dipped in a phosphate solution so they stay plump and white. They look good on the counter, but they have less flavour and they leak water in the pan, so they steam instead of browning.
- Frozen, read the label. Good frozen scallops are just scallops, sometimes with salt. If the ingredients list a phosphate, they have been soaked. Packs that say “dry” or “chemical free” are the ones to pick.
- Size. Sea scallops are often sold by how many make up a pound: U10 means fewer than 10 to the pound, so bigger. Big ones are easier to brown without overcooking the middle.
Equipment You’ll Need
One heavy pan and something to dry the scallops with.
A Closer Look at the Ingredients
Six ingredients, and each one has a job.
- Scallops 300 g, about 10 large sea scallops, for two as a main. Fresh are best. If they are frozen, buy good ones and thaw them slowly. Instead: Large raw prawns, cooked the same way.
- Butter 30 g, and nothing else in the pan. It foams, turns nutty and brown, and that brown butter is half the flavour of the dish. Instead: Clarified butter or ghee, which takes more heat without burning.
- Garlic Finely chopped. In hot butter it burns in seconds, which is why it goes in after the flip. Instead: Thinly sliced garlic, which is a little more forgiving.
- Dry white wine 50 ml, just a splash to lift the brown bits off the pan into the sauce. Instead: A splash of fish or vegetable stock.
- Lemon Squeezed in at the end. It cuts through the butter.
- Fresh parsley A tablespoon, chopped, stirred in last for colour and freshness. Instead: Chives or dill.
How to Make Pan Seared Scallops, Step by Step
Full quantities are in the recipe card below. Have everything chopped and measured before the first scallop goes in, because it all happens in a few minutes.
- Prep the Scallops. Pull off the small side muscle if it is still on. Pat the scallops very dry with kitchen paper, top and bottom, and season them with salt and pepper just before they go in the pan.The side muscle is the little tab that held the shell shut, and it stays tough however you cook it. The drying matters more than anything else in the recipe: a wet scallop steams in the pan instead of browning.Frozen scallops: thaw them in the fridge overnight, or sealed in a bag in cold water. They give off more liquid, so dry them twice.
- Sear in Butter. Melt the butter in a heavy frying pan on a medium high heat until it foams. Lay the scallops in flat side down, with space between them, and leave them alone until they are nicely brown underneath, 2 to 3 minutes.Scallops are naturally sweet, so they brown quickly in a hot pan, and the butter browns with them. The milk solids in butter catch much sooner than oil does, which is why I keep the heat at medium high and not full.Do not move them: every time you lift a scallop it stops browning. Lift the edge of one after 2 minutes to check.Butter going black: if it smells burnt, the pan is too hot. Turn it down a little.Too many: if they do not fit with space around each one, do two batches. Crowded scallops sit in their own liquid.
- Flip and Baste. Turn the scallops and add the garlic. Tilt the pan towards you, let the butter pool and spoon it over the scallops for 1 to 2 minutes, until they are opaque and just firm. Lift them onto a warm plate.Basting cooks the top with hot garlic butter, so the second side needs less time on the pan. The garlic only goes in now because in hot butter it burns in seconds.Is it done: the sides turn from see through to opaque. Press one: it should be firm with a little give. A scallop that is hard and has shrunk is overcooked and will be dry.Bay scallops: the small ones need about a minute a side.
- Wine, Lemon and Parsley. Pour the wine into the pan and let it bubble for about 30 seconds, scraping up the brown bits from the bottom. Squeeze in the lemon juice and stir in the parsley.The brown bits on the pan are flavour. The wine lifts them into the butter and turns it into a quick sauce, and the lemon cuts through the richness.No wine: a splash of stock or water does the same job.
- Serve. Spoon the garlic butter over the scallops and serve straight away.Scallops go from just right to overcooked very fast, and the crust softens as they sit, so do not let them wait.Warm plates: the butter sets on a cold plate, so warm the plates first.
Recipe Card for Pan Seared Scallops
Pan Seared Scallops in Garlic Butter
Scallops seared in butter until nicely brown, then basted with garlic and finished with white wine, lemon and parsley. About six minutes in the pan.
Equipment I Use
Ingredients
Instructions
Pull off the small side muscle if it is still on. Pat the scallops very dry with kitchen paper and season with salt and pepper just before they go in the pan.
Melt the butter in a heavy frying pan on a medium high heat until it foams. Lay the scallops in flat side down with space between them and leave them alone until nicely brown underneath, 2 to 3 minutes.
Turn the scallops and add the garlic. Tilt the pan and spoon the foaming butter over them for 1 to 2 minutes, until they are opaque and just firm. Lift them onto a warm plate.
Pour the wine into the pan and let it bubble for about 30 seconds, scraping up the brown bits. Squeeze in the lemon juice and stir in the parsley.
Spoon the garlic butter over the scallops and serve straight away.
Chef’s notes
- Dry scallops brown best. Soaked ones look glossy and very white and leak liquid into the pan.
- Frozen scallops: thaw them in the fridge overnight and dry them well before cooking.
- Bay scallops are much smaller. Give them about a minute a side.
- As a starter allow 3 to 4 scallops a person; as a main, about 5.
- Best eaten straight away. Leftovers keep in the fridge for a day.
- Cost. Cost per serving: about $8.60 at Walmart prices (15 November 2026), counting only the amounts used. The whole dish comes to about $17.25.
Nutrition per serving
Check out my other Recipes:
Serving and Storing
How many you need depends on what you serve them with. As a starter, 3 or 4 each on their own with bread for the butter. As a main, about 5 each with pasta or a green salad. For a bigger seafood dinner, try my seafood pasta, my tom yum talay or my Thai fish and prawn curry.
They are best straight from the pan. Leftovers keep in the fridge for a day and are good cold, sliced into a salad, because reheating toughens them. Do not leave cooked seafood out of the fridge for more than 2 hours.
FAQ for Pan Seared Scallops
How many scallops per person?
It depends what else is on the plate. As a starter I allow 3 to 4 large scallops each. As a main with pasta or salad, about 5.
Can I cook frozen scallops?
Yes. Thaw them in the fridge overnight, or sealed in a bag in cold water if you are short of time, never on the counter. Then dry them very well, because frozen scallops hold more water.
Why did my scallops not brown?
They were wet, the pan was not hot enough, or there were too many in it. Soaked scallops are a common cause, because they keep leaking water however much you dry them.
How do I know when scallops are cooked?
They turn opaque from the bottom up and feel firm with a little give when you press them. Large ones take about 2 to 3 minutes on the first side and 1 to 2 on the second.
Can I cook them in butter only?
Yes, I always do. Keep the heat at medium high rather than full, and if the butter starts to smell burnt, turn it down a little.
What is the side muscle?
A small, tougher strip on the side of the scallop that held the shell closed. It pulls off easily with your fingers. Some scallops come with it already taken off.
A Few Words from the Chef
Buy the best scallops you can find, dry them well and leave them alone in the butter. That is really all there is to it. If you make them, tell me in the comments what you served them with. Smacznego!
Chef Łukasz BabralExecutive chef, cooking professionally for 18 years
Follow my Culinary Journey
New recipes in your inbox, plus food & farm photography from my kitchen and allotment.
