Massaman is the Thai curry people describe as the mild one, the sweet one, or the one with potatoes in it. None of those is what actually makes it massaman. The paste does, and the recipes for it vary more than you would think.
So I read eleven of them, from Thailand, the UK, the US and Australia, and counted what each one puts in. Five ingredients appear in all eleven. Three appear in only one. And the ingredient most people assume is compulsory turns out to be a coin flip.
What all eleven agree on
| Ingredient | Recipes using it | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Dried red chillies | 11 of 11 | Thai dried chillies, with guajillo or japones substituted in three US recipes |
| Shallots | 11 of 11 | One outlier uses onion |
| Garlic | 11 of 11 | |
| Lemongrass | 11 of 11 | |
| Cumin | 11 of 11 | Whole or ground |
| Galangal, or ginger as its stated substitute | 10 of 11 | One uses ginger with no galangal mentioned |
| Coriander | 10 of 11 | Seed, whole or ground. Two also add chopped stems |
| Cardamom | 10 of 11 | |
| Cinnamon | 9 of 11 | |
| Cloves | 9 of 11 | |
| Salt | 7 of 11 | Listed as an ingredient rather than “to taste” |
| Nutmeg | 7 of 11 | Common enough to treat as core |
| Shrimp paste | 6 of 11 | A coin flip, see below |
| Makrut lime leaves or zest | 4 of 11 | |
| Mace | 2 of 11 | |
| White pepper instead of black | 2 of 11 | |
| Tamarind | 2 of 11 | |
| Peanuts ground into the paste | 2 of 11 | As opposed to added to the finished curry |
| Star anise | 1 of 11 | The only Thailand-based author in the set |
| Bay leaf | 1 of 11 | |
| Coriander root | 1 of 11 | Everyone else uses the seed |
What actually separates massaman from red curry paste
This is the part worth knowing, and five of the eleven say it outright while the rest simply do it: a red curry paste is built on fresh chillies, herbs and aromatics. Massaman adds a set of warm, dry, toasted spices on top, the cinnamon, cardamom, cloves, cumin, coriander and usually nutmeg in the table above.
That is the whole distinction. It is also why massaman tastes closer to an Indian curry than its neighbours do, which is the standard explanation across cookery writing: the dish reflects the Persian and Muslim trading routes into southern Thailand.
And the toasting is not a flourish. Dry-toasting whole spices is one of the ways Indian cooking matures spice flavour before it goes into a dish, and the point is that it makes aroma compounds that were not there before, the roasted notes you get in any browned food, layered on top of the spice’s raw smell. Toasting does not wake a spice up. It adds something.
Where the field genuinely splits
Shrimp paste is in only six of the eleven. That surprised me. Two leave it out and say so, one is vegan by design, one marks it optional, and one mentions it in the introduction and then leaves it off the ingredient list. So a vegetarian massaman paste is not a compromise, it is close to half the field, which is not what you would guess from the way shrimp paste is usually talked about.
Makrut lime leaf or zest is in four of eleven, so the citrus lift a lot of people think of as essential is a minority choice. And coriander root, the ingredient hardest to actually buy, is in exactly one. Ten use the seed, whole or ground. Two of those add chopped stems as well. If you have been hunting for coriander root, the field settled that question for you a long time ago without saying so.
Galangal is in ten of eleven, and where a substitute is given it is ginger plus lime zest rather than ginger alone. Ginger on its own is hotter and less floral, and the zest is there to put back what is missing.
The outliers, which are the interesting part
Star anise appears once, in the recipe by the only Thailand-based author in the set. Bay leaf appears once. Tamarind appears twice, in the two recipes with the strongest individual signatures. Mace twice. Ground peanuts in the paste itself, rather than stirred into the finished curry, twice.
None of those is wrong and none of them is consensus. They are the places individual cooks have put their thumbprint, and if you want to make a paste that tastes like yours rather than like a recipe, that is the list to experiment down.
How long it keeps, where the sources disagree most
Nine of the eleven give a fridge life and they range from “a few days” to a month. That is the widest disagreement in the whole set, on the one question with a safety edge to it.
| Recipe | Fridge | Freezer |
|---|---|---|
| Curious Chickpea | a few days | “longer”, not specified |
| Little Spice Jar | within a week | several months |
| Wok & Skillet | up to 1 week | up to 3 months |
| Krumpli | 7 to 10 days, under oil | yes, in ice cube trays |
| Thai-Foodie | 1 to 2 weeks | 3 to 6 months |
| Chili Pepper Madness | up to 2 weeks | 6 months or more |
| Susie Cooks Thai | up to 2 weeks | 3 months |
| The Curry Guy | 2 to 3 weeks | 2 to 3 months |
| Hungry in Thailand | up to 1 month | up to 6 months |
The modal answer is one to two weeks, and that is what I would work to. The one-month claim comes from the Thailand-based author and may well reflect a drier or saltier paste than the rest; I would not repeat it as a general figure.
Two of them add a technique worth having: pour a thin layer of oil over the top of the stored paste as an air barrier. And the freezer answer is far more settled than the fridge one. Most land on three to six months, and six of the eleven independently recommend freezing it in ice cube trays so you can take out one curry at a time.
Do you actually need to make it?
Honest answer: my own massaman curry recipe uses four tablespoons of shop-bought paste, and most weeknights that is what I would do.
The argument for making it is control rather than virtue, and the real case for it is the shop jar. Shop jars vary enormously in salt and heat and you cannot tell from the label, so the same curry can come out far too salty on one brand and too hot on another. Once you make your own, the recipe stops moving under you.
If you only change one thing, toast and grind the whole spices yourself and stir them into a shop-bought paste. That is the part that makes it massaman, and it is fifteen minutes.
How I did this
Eleven recipes with complete, quantified ingredient lists, read in full: Krumpli, RecipeTin Eats, The Curry Guy, Little Spice Jar, Thai-Foodie, Curious Chickpea, Chili Pepper Madness, Just A Pinch, Wok & Skillet, Susie Cooks Thai and Hungry in Thailand.
One notable source is missing and it is worth saying so: Hot Thai Kitchen could not be read directly, and ThaiTable.com returned a 404. Neither is included in any count on this page.
Every quantity was taken exactly as published, with nothing averaged or converted. Counts are of the eleven recipes read, so “6 of 11” means six of those eleven and not a claim about massaman paste in general.
You might also like:
