Fish Pie (Fisherman’s Pie) with Salmon, Smoked Haddock and Prawns

Share this recipe

Fish pie, or fisherman’s pie, is salmon, smoked haddock and prawns in a creamy herb sauce, baked under mashed potato until the top goes golden. My version keeps the sauce light: milk and a little stock instead of cream, with leek, carrot, dill and lemon zest through it.

How I make it: I soften the vegetables slowly, make the sauce with warm milk and thicken it with cornflour, then fold in the raw fish so it only cooks once, in the oven. A parmesan mash goes on top, and a few minutes under the grill at the end gives the ridges their colour. I like a good fish pie, creamy and filling.

Close-up of an individual fish pie with a golden, ridged parmesan mash top in a grey pie dishPin it

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

What Is Fish Pie?

Fish pie is a British dish of fish and seafood in a white sauce, topped with mashed potato and baked. Fisherman’s pie is another name for the same thing. A mix of fish works better than one kind: the salmon brings richness, the smoked haddock a smoky, salty flavour, and the prawns some sweetness.

A baked fish pie in a glass dish seen from the side, creamy fish filling under a golden mashPin it

A Closer Look at the Ingredients

  • Salmon The rich fish of the three, and it keeps its colour in the sauce. Instead: trout, or more white fish.
  • Smoked haddock Most of the flavour of the pie comes from here. It is salty, which is why the stock goes in carefully. Instead: smoked cod, or unsmoked haddock or cod with a little more seasoning.
  • Prawns, raw They go in raw with the fish and turn pink in the oven. Instead: leave them out and add the same weight of white fish.
  • Leek, carrot, celery and shallot Diced small and cooked slowly, they give the sauce body and sweetness. Instead: an onion for the shallot.
  • Dill, parsley, thyme and lemon zest Dill goes well with fish, and the zest keeps the creamy sauce fresh. Instead: dried thyme is fine; the dill and parsley should be fresh.
  • Milk and stock The base of the sauce, lighter than cream. Instead: fish stock instead of vegetable stock.
  • Cornflour (cornstarch) Thickens the milk without a roux. Instead: a roux of 40 g butter and 40 g plain flour.
  • Floury potatoes Russet or Yukon Gold mash smooth and light. Instead: Maris Piper or King Edward in the UK.
  • Parmesan, butter and yoghurt For the mash. The parmesan browns on top. Instead: milk for the yoghurt, cheddar for the parmesan.

Equipment You’ll Need

How to Make Fish Pie, Step by Step

Full quantities are in the recipe card below.

  1. Shallot and Garlic. Heat 2 tbsp of olive oil in a large deep frying pan over a medium heat. Add the diced shallot and the minced garlic and fry for about 5 minutes, until soft but not brown.Keep the heat moderate: garlic burns quickly, and burnt garlic makes the whole sauce bitter.
  2. Cook the Vegetables. Add the carrot, leek, celery and the 50 g of butter and cook on a medium heat for around 15 minutes, until soft and lightly coloured. While they cook, warm the 700 ml of milk in a separate pan, and put the diced potatoes on to boil in salted water for the mash.Cut everything small, so it softens in the time and there are no hard lumps of carrot inside the pie. Doing the milk and the potatoes now means everything is ready at the same time.
  3. Make the Sauce. Add the bay leaves, thyme, parsley, dill and lemon zest to the vegetables. Pour in the warm milk, crumble in the stock cube, add black pepper and simmer for 5 minutes.Go easy with the stock: the smoked haddock is salty, and the parmesan in the mash adds more, so taste at the end rather than now. The lemon zest keeps the creamy sauce tasting fresh.
  4. Thicken the Sauce. In a small bowl, mix the 2 tbsp of cornflour with the 50 ml of cold water until smooth, then stir it into the sauce. Keep stirring as it comes back to a simmer, and when it thickens, take the pan off the heat and check the seasoning.Always mix cornflour with cold water first, or it goes lumpy in the hot milk. The sauce should coat the back of a spoon, because the fish lets out juice as it bakes.Roux instead: if you prefer flour, melt 40 g of butter, stir in 40 g of plain flour, cook it for a minute, then whisk in the milk.
  5. Add the Fish. Stir in the 50 g of breadcrumbs, then the diced salmon, smoked haddock and prawns, and pour everything into a 2.5 litre baking dish.The fish goes in raw, so it cooks only once, in the oven, and stays in pieces instead of breaking up. Fish out the bay leaves now if you can find them.Individual pies: share the filling between four or five small pie dishes, like the ones in my photos.
  6. Mash and Top. Drain the potatoes well and mash them with the 50 g of butter and the yoghurt, then add the parmesan and a pinch of nutmeg and taste. Spoon the mash over the filling, starting at the edges, or pipe it on with a piping bag.Floury potatoes make a light, smooth mash. Working from the edges in seals the filling, so the sauce does not push up through the middle. Rough the top up with a fork: the ridges are what go crisp and golden.
  7. Bake. Bake for 30 minutes at 160C fan (180C conventional, 350F), then switch the oven to the grill at 180C for about 5 minutes to colour the top.Watch it under the grill, it goes from golden to burnt quickly. The centre should be steaming hot: a probe in the middle should read 75C (165F).
  8. Rest and Serve. Take the pie out and leave it to cool for 5 minutes before serving.Straight from the oven the sauce is very hot and runny. After 5 minutes it settles, and each spoonful holds together on the plate.
Fish pie filling in the pan: creamy milk sauce with diced carrot, leek and herbsPin it
Fish pie in a glass dish topped with forked mashed potato and black pepper, ready for the ovenPin it

Recipe Card for Fish Pie

Recipe Card
Fish Pie with Salmon, Smoked Haddock and Prawns

Fish Pie with Salmon, Smoked Haddock and Prawns

A creamy fish pie, also called fisherman's pie: salmon, smoked haddock and prawns in a light herb and milk sauce with leek and dill, under a parmesan mash baked golden.

Be the first to rate it
Prep
25 min
Cook
1 hr 5 min
Resting
5 min
Total
1 hr 35 min
Serves
5
Per serving
744 kcal
Cost per serving
$4.75
Scale the recipe
Quantities update as you change it
5 portions
Switch units

Equipment I Use

Ingredients

For the Filling
For the Mash

Instructions

Tap a step to tick it off as you cook.
1
Shallot and Garlic

Fry the shallot and garlic in the olive oil on a medium heat for 5 minutes, until soft.

2
Cook the Vegetables

Add the carrot, leek, celery and butter and cook on a medium heat for around 15 minutes. Meanwhile warm the milk in a separate pan and boil the potatoes in salted water for the mash.

3
Make the Sauce

Add the bay leaves, thyme, parsley, dill and lemon zest. Pour in the milk, add the stock cube and black pepper and simmer for 5 minutes.

4
Thicken the Sauce

Mix the cornflour with the cold water and stir it into the sauce. When it thickens, take it off the heat and check the seasoning.

Fish pie filling in the pan: creamy milk sauce with diced carrot, leek and herbs
5
Add the Fish

Stir in the breadcrumbs, then the diced salmon, smoked haddock and prawns, and transfer everything into a 2.5 litre baking dish.

6
Mash and Top

Mash the potatoes with the butter and yoghurt, add the parmesan and nutmeg, taste, and top the pie with a spoon or a piping bag.

Fish pie in a glass dish topped with forked mashed potato and black pepper, ready for the oven
7
Bake

Bake for 30 minutes at 160C fan (180C conventional, 350F), then switch to the grill at 180C for about 5 minutes to colour the top.

A baked fish pie in a glass dish seen from the side, creamy fish filling under a golden mash
8
Rest and Serve

Leave the pie to cool for 5 minutes before serving, so the sauce settles and does not run all over the plate.

Two individual fish pies with golden mash tops, a large fish pie in a glass dish behind them
Cooked it? Rate it right here.
One tap. No name, no email, and it counts straight away.
Chef’s notes
  • 160C is a fan oven. Conventional: 180C (350F).
  • Go easy with the stock: the smoked haddock is salty. Taste at the end.
  • The centre should be steaming hot, 75C (165F) on a probe.
  • Individual pies: share the filling between four or five small pie dishes.
  • To freeze, assemble with a cold filling, wrap and freeze unbaked. Defrost overnight in the fridge and bake 15 to 20 minutes longer.
  • Leftovers keep 3 days in total in the fridge. Reheat once, until steaming hot in the middle.
  • Cost. Cost per serving: about $4.75 at Walmart prices (18 November 2026), counting only the amounts used. The whole dish comes to about $23.70. Walmart does not sell smoked haddock, so I counted cod at its price.
Nutrition per serving
744 kcalProtein 41.7 gCarbs 64.6 gFat 36 gSat fat 16.4 gFibre 5.1 gSugar 13.1 gSodium 1521 mgServing 557 g

Check out my other Recipes:

Two individual fish pies with golden mash tops, a large fish pie in a glass dish behind themPin it

Storing, Freezing and Reheating

Cool leftovers quickly, cover them and keep them in the fridge for 3 days in total, counting the day you made the pie.

To freeze, it is best assembled but not baked: let the filling go completely cold before the mash goes on, wrap the dish well and freeze it. Eat it within about 2 to 3 months for the best texture. Defrost it in the fridge overnight, then bake it from cold, adding about 15 to 20 minutes, until the centre is steaming hot.

Reheat leftovers until steaming hot all the way through, 75C (165F) in the middle, and only once. My guide to cooking temperatures and guide to reheating food have the details.

What to Serve With Fish Pie

Some white wine goes very well with fish pie, and a side salad if you want it a bit fancy. If you like a pie with mash on top, try my shepherd’s pie too, or for a pastry one, my chicken and leek pie. There are more ideas in my list of potato recipes.

FAQ for Fish Pie

Can I freeze fish pie?

Yes, and it is best frozen before baking. Let the filling go cold, top it with the mash, wrap it and freeze. Defrost it in the fridge overnight and bake it from cold for 15 to 20 minutes longer, until the centre is steaming hot.

Can I make fish pie ahead?

Yes. Make the sauce, let it cool completely, then stir in the fish and top with the mash. Keep it covered in the fridge and bake it within 24 hours, adding about 15 minutes because it goes in cold.

Can I use frozen fish or a fish pie mix?

Yes. A ready fish pie mix from the supermarket works and saves cutting three kinds of fish. Defrost frozen fish in the fridge, then drain it and pat it dry, because the water it lets go would thin the sauce.

Does fish pie have boiled eggs in it?

Some recipes add quartered hard boiled eggs. Mine does not, but two eggs pushed into the filling before the mash goes on will not change anything else.

Why is my fish pie watery?

Usually the sauce was too thin to start with, or the fish was wet. Cook the sauce until it coats a spoon before the fish goes in, and dry any defrosted fish well.

A Few Words from the Chef

I like a good fish pie: creamy and filling. It is an old recipe of mine, and I have not made it for a long time, so I will have to make it again soon.Chef Łukasz BabralChef Łukasz BabralExecutive chef, cooking professionally for 18 years

Enjoyed it? Share it

Made it? Tell me how it went

Tell me what you changed and how it turned out, or ask a question about the recipe. No email needed.

Rate it too, if you made it (optional)

Please read the Comment Policy before you comment. Comments are for adults and are moderated.