Caribbean Beef and Potato Pasty (Trinidad Aloo Pie)

I made these for the first time at the chef academy, and what struck me straight away was how familiar the idea was underneath: beef and potato, spiced and wrapped in pastry, eaten in your hand. A Caribbean Cornish pasty, more or less, which is where the name of this recipe comes from. On the islands you will find them sold hot from stalls and vans, and once you taste one it is easy to see why.

The beef is marinated and slow-cooked until tender, then wrapped in a soft dough and shallow-fried until golden. The flavour comes from Trinidad’s mix of African, Creole and Indian cooking, which gives the filling real warmth and depth.

If you love Caribbean spice, try my Jamaican Lamb Curry next.

“As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.”

PPin it

What Is Trinidad Aloo Pie?

Aloo pie is a Trinidadian street-food favourite, a soft fried pastry stuffed with spiced potato and, in this version, seasoned beef. “Aloo” is the Hindi word for potato, which is a clue to where it comes from.

Trinidad’s food is a real mix of African, Indian, European and Chinese influences, and the aloo pie is the Indian side of that story: it grew out of the samosa that indentured labourers brought with them in the nineteenth century, then took on a life of its own on the island. It is best eaten warm, often split and filled with a spoon of channa or chutney.

Aloo Pie, Samosa or Beef Patty?

All three are spiced filling wrapped in dough, and they are genuinely different things. A samosa is small and triangular, and usually deep fried in a thin pastry. An aloo pie is much larger, four to six inches across, a half-moon of soft leavened dough that puffs in the oil rather than shattering. A Jamaican beef patty is a different island and a different technique altogether: turmeric-yellow shortcrust, filled with minced beef and baked rather than fried.

Trinidad has its own beef pie as well, and it is not this either. That one is a baked shortcrust, made with shortening and butter, and it belongs to weddings and limes rather than to a roadside stall. Mine sits between the two: the diced-beef curry of a Trinidad beef pie, cooked the way an aloo pie is cooked. That is deliberate, and it is the reason this recipe exists rather than another mashed-potato one.

A Closer Look at the Ingredients

• Beef shin. A hard-working cut, full of connective tissue, which is exactly what you want for a long simmer: it turns meltingly soft where a lean cut would only go dry. Diced small so it fits inside a pie rather than fighting the pastry.
• The marinade, which is green seasoning in all but name. Spring onions (scallions, in Trinidad), coriander, garlic and tomato blitzed into the meat before it ever sees heat is the Trinidadian habit known as green seasoning. In Trinidad the herb is chadon beni, a broader, stronger relative of coriander; coriander is the standard stand-in everywhere else and is what this uses.
• Curry powder, and a word about geera. Trinidadian curry powder leans heavier on coriander and cumin than a British mild curry powder does, and most Trini cooks reach for geera, which is roasted ground cumin, as well. The ground cumin here is doing that job.
• Turmeric in the dough. It is there for colour rather than flavour, and it is traditional. In the Caribbean turmeric is often called saffron, which throws people the first time they read a recipe from the islands.
• Cardamom in the dough. This one is mine. No Trinidadian recipe I have read puts it in, and it is a small amount, but it gives the pastry a faint warm perfume that lifts it above plain fried dough. Leave it out if you would rather be strictly traditional.
• Baking powder, not yeast. Both are used in Trinidad and they give you different things. Yeast makes a thicker, chewier, bready pocket; baking powder makes a lighter, crisper shell that comes together in half an hour instead of two. This dough is the quick one.
• Waxy potatoes. They hold their shape through fifty minutes of simmering, so the filling stays a beef and potato curry rather than collapsing into a mash.

Equipment You Will Need

Ingredient Substitutions

• Beef shin. Any stewing cut works: chuck, braising steak, shin of any animal. Keep the dice small. Chicken thigh is the swap Trinidadian cooks make most often, and it needs about half the simmering time.
• The meat itself. Leave it out and you have the traditional aloo pie: spiced potato, nothing else. Split peas, channa or lentils cooked down with the same spices are all genuine Trini fillings, and callaloo with cheese is a common one too.
• Coriander. Chadon beni if you can find it, which is what Trinidad actually uses and is stronger and broader-leaved. Otherwise coriander, stalks and all, is the accepted stand-in.
• Curry powder. A Caribbean or Trinidadian blend if you have one, since it is built around coriander and cumin. Madras curry powder is closer than a generic mild one.
• Plain flour. Spelt or wholemeal both work and both drink more liquid, so hold a little water back and add it as you go rather than tipping it all in.
• Baking powder. A teaspoon of fast-action yeast, proved in the warm water for ten minutes first, gives the thicker chewier pocket. It needs an hour or so to rise rather than a thirty-minute rest.

How to Make Aloo Beef Pies, Step by Step

Full quantities are in the recipe card below. The filling is made first and cooled completely, which is not a matter of tidiness: warm filling steams inside the dough and forces the seam apart in the oil. Almost every burst pie comes back to that.

1. Marinate the beef. Salt, pepper, spring onions, coriander, tomato, ketchup, curry powder and lime juice, worked into the diced shin. Overnight in the fridge is better and half an hour is enough. This is green seasoning by another name, and it is why the meat tastes seasoned all the way through rather than just wearing a sauce.

PPin it

2. Build the base and bloom the spices. Three tablespoons of oil over a medium heat, then the onion, garlic and chilli until they are properly golden, about five minutes. Take your time over that: this is the only browning the whole dish gets, and pale onions make a flat filling however long you simmer it afterwards. Then the curry powder and ground cumin go into the hot oil for two minutes, followed by four tablespoons of water, which you let cook away completely. Frying ground spices in fat before any real liquid arrives lets their aromas react with one another, so they taste like one blended spice rather than three separate powders, and the splash of water stops them catching in the two minutes it takes.
3. In with the beef. The marinated meat and every scrap of its marinade go into the pan, stirred through the spiced base, then the lid goes on, the heat comes down and it simmers gently for thirty-five minutes. Do not drain the marinade off: it is half the seasoning, and it becomes the liquid the beef cooks in. Shin needs this time and a low heat, because what makes it tender is connective tissue slowly turning to gelatine, and rushing it on a high flame only tightens the meat.

PPin it

4. Potatoes, peas and stock, then reduce it right down. They go in with the water and the stock cube, up to a boil and then straight back down to a simmer, and from here it cooks uncovered for about fifty minutes until it has thickened and most of the liquid has gone. Uncovered is the whole point of this step: you are not just cooking the potato through, you are reducing a stew into something that will sit inside a pastry without leaking out of the seam. If it still looks loose at the end, a tablespoon of cornflour slaked in a little cold water and stirred through will pull it together in a couple of minutes. Taste it properly now and get the seasoning right, because this is the last moment you can: once it is sealed inside dough you have no way back. Two faults turn up again and again with this sort of filling, in opposite directions: flat and underseasoned, or harsh and a bit raw tasting. The chilli answers the first and the lime juice answers the second, which is why both are in the recipe, so if it is still not right the lever you want is more of one or the other rather than more curry powder. Then tip it out onto a large plate and spread it thin, which cools it far faster than leaving it in the pan, and leave it until it is stone cold. Warm filling is the single commonest reason these burst open in the oil.

PPin it

5. Make the dough. Sieved flour with the baking powder, salt, turmeric and cardamom, then the water, brought together and kneaded into a smooth ball. Add the water gradually rather than all at once, because flours vary in how much they drink and a slack dough is far harder to seal. Cover it and let it rest at least thirty minutes: the rest relaxes the gluten and is the difference between dough that rolls out and dough that pings back.
6. Roll and fill. Eight even balls, each rolled to a circle of about 10 cm on a floured surface. Filling in the middle, edges dampened, folded over and pinched firmly, then crimped with a fork on both sides. Do not roll them too thin chasing a delicate pastry: thin patches are where they split, and a little thickness is what lets the dough puff.

PPin it

7. Rest them under a cloth. Lay the shaped pies out and cover them so they do not dry out and crack while you finish the rest.
8. Fry them. Oil to 170°C, two at a time, for two to three minutes a side. Half a litre of oil in a wide pan is enough to shallow fry them and enough to hold its temperature when two cold pies go in, which matters more than depth does. Spoon a little of the hot oil over the tops as they cook and they puff and colour far more evenly. Go by what you can see rather than the clock: deep gold, and visibly puffed. This is the step people get wrong in both directions, and the temperature is why. Too hot and the shell sets before the inside has risen, which is where a hard, crunchy pie comes from; too cool and the dough sits there drinking oil instead of sealing against it. Drain them on kitchen paper and eat them hot.

PPin it

PPin it

9. Serve them hot. Mango chutney, salad and whatever dressing you like. They are at their best within minutes of leaving the pan, and that is not a garnish note, it is the whole nature of the thing.

PPin it

Recipe Card for Aloo Beef Pies

Recipe Card

Caribbean Beef and Potato Pasty (Trinidad Aloo Pie)

Crisp fried Caribbean pasties with a curried beef and potato filling, my beef version of Trinidad street-food aloo pie. Makes eight, best eaten hot.

★★★★☆ 4.4 from 7 votes · Rate this recipe

Print Pin

Prep

45 min

Cook

1 hr 45 min

Dough Resting

30 min

Total

3 hrs

Serves

8

Per serving

396 kcal

Scale the recipe

Quantities update as you change it

−

8 pies

+

Switch units Metric US

Cook mode Keeps the screen awake while you cook

Equipment I Use

Hybrid Non Stick Frying PanDeep Fry ProbeRolling Pin

Ingredients

Reset ticks

Ingredients for the marinade:

400 g Beef Shin, small dice (or other stewing cut) ½ tsp Salt ½ tsp Black Pepper 2 Spring Onions, sliced and washed 1 handful Coriander 1 Tomato, medium size, diced 1 tbsp Ketchup 1 tsp Mild Curry Powder ½ Lime, juice only

Ingredients for the Aloo filling:

100 g Peas 400 g Potatoes, waxy type, peeled and cut in small dice (keep them in water until needed) 1 tsp Ground Cumin 1½ tbsp Mild Curry Powder 1 Red chilli, small dice 3 Garlic clove, minced 1 Onion, medium size, sliced 3 tbsp Vegetable Oil 1 Beef stock cube 600 ml Water 1 tbsp Cornflour, optional, to thicken the filling if needed

Ingredients for the Aloo pastry:

280 g Plain Flour, sieved ¼ tsp Ground Cardamom ½ tsp Ground Turmeric ½ tsp Salt 2 tsp Baking Powder 175 ml Water 500 ml Vegetable Oil , for shallow frying

Instructions

Tap a step to tick it off as you cook.

Instructions for the Aloo Pie filling:

1

Marinating the Beef

To start off, marinate the beef with a blend of salt, pepper, spring onions, coriander, tomato, ketchup, curry powder and lime juice. You may choose to marinate the beef overnight or just before cooking.

2

Preparing the Spiced Onions and Garlic

In a frying pan, heat 3 tbsp of oil over medium heat. Introduce onion, garlic, and chilli, cooking until they turn golden-brown, around 5 minutes. Incorporate the curry powder and ground cumin, cooking for an additional 2 minutes. Pour in 4tbsp of water, allowing it to evaporate completely over the next 5 minutes.

3

Cooking the Marinated Beef

Incorporate the marinated beef into the pan, mixing thoroughly. Cover the pan, reduce the heat, and simmer for 35 minutes.

4

Adding Potatoes and Finishing the Beef Mixture

As the beef continues to cook, introduce potatoes and water, peas, followed by a beef stock cube. Allow it to come to a boil before reducing to a simmer. Continue cooking uncovered for about 50 minutes or until it thickens and most of the water evaporates. Taste and adjust seasonings accordingly. Once done, transfer to a large plate, spreading it out to expedite cooling and ease handling. If the filling does not seem thick enough, mix 1 tablespoon of cornflour with a small amount of water, then stir it into the filling and cook for a few more minutes until it thickens.

Instructions for the pastry and assembly:

5

Preparing the Dough

Begin dough preparation by combining sieved flour with baking powder, salt, turmeric, and cardamom. Knead this mixture into a ball, cover, and let it rest for a minimum of 30 minutes.

6

Forming the Beef Pies

Dust your workspace with flour, dividing the dough into 8 even balls. Roll each into approximately 10cm diameter circles. Spoon the beef mixture into each circle’s centre, sealing by folding and pinching the edges. Moistening the edges may aid in ensuring they adhere.

7

Arranging Pies for Cooking

Position the pies on a cloth, potentially covering them with another cloth to retain moisture.

8

Frying the Pies

Heat the oil to 170°C (340°F) and shallow fry the pies two at a time, for 2 to 3 minutes a side, until deep golden and puffed. Spoon a little of the hot oil over the tops as they cook so they colour and puff evenly. Go by colour rather than the clock, and if the first one is at all doughy inside, take the heat down a little and give the next ones longer. Drain on kitchen paper and serve hot.

9

Serving the Beef Pies

Once all pies are cooked, serve them with mango chutney, salad, and dressing of your choice for a complete meal.

★

Cooked it? Rate it right here.

One tap. No name, no email, and it counts straight away.

Chef’s notes＋

Rest the dough. Thirty minutes is the minimum. Rolled straight after kneading it springs back and you will fight it into shape rather than roll it.

The filling has to be cold. Warm filling softens the pastry from the inside, and a soft pie tears as you seal it. Spread it out on a plate to cool it quickly.

Thick, not wet. If the filling still looks loose after the uncovered simmer, stir in the tablespoon of cornflour slaked in a little cold water and give it a few minutes more. A wet filling will not let the edges seal.

170°C, two at a time. Hotter and the outside colours before the pastry cooks through; cooler and they drink the oil. Frying more than two at once drops the temperature and does the same thing. Go by colour rather than the clock.

They are a hot food. The pastry softens as it cools, so eat them within the hour if you can. You can bake them instead, brushed with oil, but they come out closer to a pasty than to the fried street-food version.

Nutrition per serving＋

396 kcalProtein 17.1 gCarbs 41.9 gFat 17.9 gSat fat 3.1 gFibre 4.2 gSugar 3 gSodium 563 mgServing 209 g

Caribbean Beef and Potato Pasty (Trinidad Aloo Pie) · https://chefsbinge.com/caribbean-beef-and-potato-pasty-trinidad-aloo-pie/

PPin it

Variations

• The traditional potato one. Leave the beef out entirely and season the potato hard. That is the aloo pie sold on the street in Trinidad, and it is what most people mean by the name.
• Baked instead of fried. Twenty-five to thirty minutes at 180°C. Lighter, and honestly a different food: you lose the puff and the blistered surface that the oil gives you.
• Chicken, tuna or salt fish. All three turn up in Trinidadian kitchens as the household variation. Chicken thigh needs about half the simmering time of shin.
• Split peas or channa. Cooked down with the same spices until thick. This is the closest thing to what gets spooned inside a split aloo pie anyway.
• Party size. Roll them smaller and you have a tray of one-bite pies, which fry in less time and disappear faster than you can make them.

Storing, Freezing and Reheating

These are meant to be eaten hot. They go soft as they cool, and no amount of technique gets round it, which is why they are sold from a stall and eaten standing up. Cooked ones keep in the fridge for two days and want reheating in a hot oven for eight to ten minutes rather than a microwave, which turns the crust to leather.

The freezer is the better answer, and freeze them raw. Shape them, lay them on a tray so they are not touching, freeze them solid and then bag them. Fry them straight from frozen with the oil a shade cooler and a few extra minutes, and they come out very close to fresh. Cooked-then-frozen works too but you will never get the same shell back.

🍽 In Trinidad an aloo pie is usually split open along the seam after frying and stuffed with curried channa, then given tamarind sauce, mango or cucumber chutney and a little pepper sauce. It is worth doing at least once, even with a beef filling. Otherwise mango chutney on the side, a sharp salad, and something cold to drink.

A Few Words from the Chef

They were something genuinely new to me at the time, and they have stayed in my repertoire ever since. Tell me in the comments how yours turned out.

FAQ for Caribbean Beef and Potato Pasty (Aloo Pie)